Chapter 10: Philosophical Bastards
Buddha uses two words. For the outside he uses dhatu, the object. Philosophy is concerned with the object. It forgets the observer, it remembers the observed. The arrow is pointed towards the without, dhatu, the object. And for the inner journey Buddha uses the word chitta, subjectivity. When you are moving inwards psychology is created, when you are moving outwards philosophy is created. And science is a growth of philosophy.
But the modern psychology, the so-called psychology, is not psychology in the sense that Buddha uses the word “psychology” because the modern psychology again goes on thinking about mind, in an objective way. It uses the philosophical method. Hence it misses the point. That is the difference between modern psychology and the real psychology.
Gurdjieff used to say that the real psychology has yet to be born. What does he mean by real psychology? Is Sigmund Freud not a real psychologist? Is Carl Gustav Jung not a real psychologist? Is Adler not a real psychologist? No, they all think in the objective way. Their psychologies are nothing but philosophies. They think about mind; the mind is taken as an object. They think about the mind from the outside. They watch. They observe. They analyze. They dissect. But the observer remains outside; the observer thinks.
Gurdjieff says that the real psychology us yet to be born. In a sense he is right, in a sense he is not. If we think about Freud, Jung, Adler and company then he is right, but if we think about Patanjali, Buddha, Lao Tzu, Hui Neng, then he is wrong. The real psychology has existed for millennia. The real psychology has existed for so long that we have forgotten about it. The new, the so-called psychology is very immature. It is a very late arrival just one hundred years old. It is very childish.
The real psychology is the psychology of the buddhas. The real psychology is to go inside your being - not to watch how rats behave, not to watch how others behave, not to go on looking outside, but to go inside with closed eyes, deep, meditatively, alert, fully alert, watching what happens inside. Go on dropping from the outside into your inside, into your inferiority. Go on forgetting the world of objects, then the world of thoughts, then the world of feelings - go on dropping out, go on dropping out. A moment comes when your consciousness is there without any content.
To know this consciousness is to know what real psychology is - the psychology of the buddhas.
And you ask: What is religion? The division between the “out” and “in” is still a division, so the “in” is also not very much “in,” it is part of the “out,” it is another aspect of the same coin. On one side is written “out,” on another “in.” So philosophy and psychology are two aspects of the same coin: one is extroversion, another is introversion.